Hypothyroidism impairs skeletal muscle regeneration after injury by altering myogenic and nonmyogenic pathways

Skeletal muscle regeneration after injury is impaired during hypothyroidism. To assess the impact of thyroid hormone deficiency on muscle regeneration, we induced injury with cardiotoxin (CTX) in the tibialis anterior muscle (TAM) of hypothyroid mice, compared with euthyroid control mice, and monitored recovery over 2 months (Figure 1A). Hypothyroidism was induced in mice 3 weeks before injury and maintained for the duration of the study. We confirmed that the dietary/propylthiouracil regimen produced systemic hypothyroidism before muscle injury, by measuring circulating T3 levels at 3 key time points (Supplemental Figure 1).

Skeletal muscle regeneration after injury: hypothyroid versus control.Figure 1

Skeletal muscle regeneration after injury: hypothyroid versus control. (A) Experimental design overview. Tibialis anterior muscles (TAMs) were collected from control and hypothyroid mice before injury and 4, 7, 14, and 28 days and 2 months after cardiotoxin-induced injury. Created in BioRender (Aguiari P, 2026, https://BioRender.com/9ywq1dw). (B) Immunofluorescence of TAM sections from control and hypothyroid mice before and 7, 14, and 28 days and 2 months after cardiotoxin-induced injury. Red, laminin; blue, nuclei (DAPI). Scale bars: 50 μm. (C) Scatter dot plot of minimum Feret diameter of TAM fibers from control and hypothyroid mice before and 7, 14, and 28 days and 2 months after injury. (D) Table showing the percentage decrease of minimum Feret diameter of regenerating skeletal muscle fibers in control and hypothyroid mice relative to the uninjured muscle. Data are presented as mean ± SEM. n = 3. One-way ANOVA and paired 2-tailed Student’s t tests were used for statistical analysis. ****P < 0.001, in hypothyroid compared with time point–matched control fibers. The experiment was repeated 3 times independently under identical conditions. CTRL, control; HYPO, hypothyroid; CTX, cardiotoxin; NI, before injury; d, days after injury; m, months after injury.

Uninjured hypothyroid muscle fibers were significantly smaller than those of control mice, as measured by minimal Feret diameter (Figure 1, B and C). At 4 days after injury (dpi), both groups exhibited similar histological appearance, with no major morphological differences. However, starting at day 7, the hypothyroid group displayed a marked and sustained reduction in myofiber size compared with controls. This included significantly smaller cross-sectional areas and minimal Feret diameters across all subsequent time points (Figure 1, B and C). Notably, the degree of myofiber size loss after injury, calculated as the percentage decrease relative to uninjured muscle, was significantly greater in hypothyroid mice, as shown in Figure 1D.

These findings indicate that hypothyroidism delays muscle fiber growth during regeneration and exacerbates muscle fiber atrophy following injury. The persistence of smaller fiber size up to 2 months after injury suggests incomplete recovery and impaired regenerative capacity in the hypothyroid group.

scRNA-seq reveals altered muscle-resident cell dynamics in hypothyroid mice. To investigate the molecular effects of hypothyroidism on skeletal muscle regeneration, we performed scRNA-seq on TAM from control and hypothyroid mice at 0, 5, and 14 dpi, capturing MuSC proliferation (5 days) and differentiation/remodeling (14 days) phases (Figure 2A). After quality control, the scRNA-seq datasets contained an average of 3,735 ± 1,786 cells per sample, and the integrated dataset included a total of 22,409 cells. Unsupervised graph-based clustering of the integrated data identified 9 distinct clusters (Supplemental Figure 2, A and B, and Supplemental Dataset 1). Based on differential expression of canonical markers (13, 15) and by combining the FAP clusters into one single cluster, we reclassified these 9 clusters into 7 broad groups of known muscle-resident cell types, shown by 2D t-distributed stochastic neighbor embedding (t-SNE) (Figure 2, B and C, and Supplemental Dataset 2). FAPs represented the dominant cluster (46.8%), followed by endothelial/mesenchymal cells (15.5%), lymphoid cells (B, T, and NK cells) (14.4%), myeloid cells (monocytes and macrophages) (13.9%), a cluster of mixed immune cells (1.8%), myogenic progenitors (5.6%, cells expressing Pax7, Myod1, or Myog), and a small population of mature myocytes (6%, expressing Myh1 and Acta1, a marker of terminally differentiated cells). Hypothyroid muscles showed distinct cell dynamics: uninjured samples had a 3.8-fold increase in myocytes, while at 5 dpi, FAPs and myogenic progenitors increased 2.2- and 2.3-fold, respectively, compared with controls. By 14 days, hypothyroid samples exhibited a 2.0-fold increase in lymphoid cells and a 2.4-fold increase in monocytes and macrophages, and a 2.9-fold drop in myocytes (Figure 2, D and E), suggesting altered cellular coordination during repair.

scRNA-seq of TAM shows different muscle-resident cell dynamics in responseFigure 2

scRNA-seq of TAM shows different muscle-resident cell dynamics in response to injury in hypothyroid versus control mice. (A) Experimental design overview. Single cells were collected from TAMs isolated from control and hypothyroid mice before injury and 5 and 14 days after cardiotoxin-induced injury, and subjected to scRNA-seq followed by downstream analysis. Created in BioRender (Aguiari P, 2026, https://BioRender.com/rz1yprc). (B) t-SNE embedding of integrated dataset from control and hypothyroid muscle scRNA-seq datasets from all the time points, colored by population. (C) Bubble plot showing the expression of canonical markers in each population. Average gene expression values are scaled. (D) t-SNE embedding of integrated dataset from control and hypothyroid scRNA-seq data colored by population and grouped by time point. (E) Graph showing the relative proportion of each cell type in control and hypothyroid regenerating muscles at the different time points, shown as a percentage. Number of cells for each sample: CTRL NI, 2,303; CTRL 5d, 4,852; CTRL 14d, 6,588; HYPO NI, 1,055; HYPO 5d, 4,312; HYPO 14d, 3,299.

Hypothyroidism reduces myogenic-lineage heterogeneity. To examine how hypothyroidism influences transcriptional programs during muscle regeneration, we focused on myogenic-lineage cells from integrated control and hypothyroid datasets across regeneration stages. We selected the myogenic progenitor and myocyte clusters, and we initially identified 1,711 cells. After exclusion of 2 subpopulations enriched in glial cell, Schwann cell, and erythrocyte markers (Supplemental Figure 2B, Supplemental Figure 3, and Supplemental Dataset 3), the final analysis included 1,463 myogenic cells.

Pseudo-bulk principal component analysis (PCA) captured global transcriptional trends. Principal component 1 (PC1), explaining 71.08% of the variance, separated noninjured (NI) samples from samples 5 dpi. At 14 dpi, control samples clustered closely with NI, suggesting recovery, while hypothyroid samples diverged along both PC1 and PC2, indicating persistent transcriptional alterations (Figure 3A).

Hypothyroidism alters transcriptional profiles, cellular composition, and rFigure 3

Hypothyroidism alters transcriptional profiles, cellular composition, and regenerative gene programs in the myogenic lineage during muscle regeneration. (A) 2D principal component analysis (PCA) plot for control and hypothyroid myogenic-lineage cells at the different time points before injury and 5 and 14 dpi. (B) t-SNE visualization of control myogenic scRNA-seq data, with color-coded clusters. (C) t-SNE visualization of control myogenic scRNA-seq data, color-coded by cluster and grouped by time point. (D) Graph depicting the relative proportions of each cluster in control myogenic-lineage cells across different time points shown as percentage. Number of cells for each sample: CTRL NI, 163; CTRL 5d, 201; CTRL 14d, 344. (E) t-SNE visualization of hypothyroid myogenic-lineage scRNA-seq data colored by cluster. (F) t-SNE visualization of hypothyroid myogenic-lineage scRNA-seq data colored by cluster and grouped by time points. (G) Graph showing the relative proportion of each cluster in hypothyroid myogenic-lineage cells at different time points. Number of cells for each sample: HYPO NI, 208; HYPO 5d, 399; HYPO 14d, 148. CTRL, control; HYPO, hypothyroid.

To explore temporal and condition-specific changes, we analyzed hypothyroid and control myogenic groups separately. This yielded 708 cells from control and 755 from hypothyroid samples. In control muscles, unsupervised clustering identified 6 distinct clusters that we classified based on expression of canonical myogenic and cell cycle markers (Supplemental Figure 4A and Supplemental Dataset 4): quiescent/activated progenitors (expressing Pax7, Myf5, Ccnd1, and Cdk6), present across all time points; proliferating myoblasts (expressing Ccne1, Cdk2, Ccna2, Cdk1, and Myog), peaking at 5 dpi; two Myod1+ progenitor clusters, Myod1+ I (expressing Pax7, Myf5, Ccne1, and Ccne2, enriched in NI muscles) and Myod1+ II (expressing Myh6, Myl1, Acta1, and Myh4, enriched at 14 days), representing cells poised for differentiation; and two differentiated myocyte clusters (Myocytes I and II), expressing Myh1 and Myh4, respectively, both present at baseline and 14 dpi (Figure 3, B–D).

Based on Gene Ontology (GO) analyses of differentially expressed genes, Myocytes I displayed enrichment for pathways that include mTOR signaling, mitochondrial translation, tricarboxylic acid cycle, and respiratory electron transport chain, strongly suggesting that these cells adopt a transcriptional program characteristic of oxidative, metabolically active muscle fibers (17, 18). In contrast, Myocytes II exhibited enrichment for GO pathways such as Rho GTPase signaling, cell cycle progression, translation initiation complex formation, HSF1 activation, and VEGF-VEGFR pathway (Supplemental Figure 5 and Supplemental Dataset 5).

Unsupervised graph-based clustering of hypothyroid myogenic cells identified only 4 clusters (Figure 3E, Supplemental Figure 4B, and Supplemental Dataset 6), indicating reduced heterogeneity. These included a single Myod1+ population spanning NI and 14 dpi; two proliferating clusters (Proliferating I and II), both expressing cell cycle (Ccne1, Cdk1, Ccna2, Ccnb1) and cell cycle exit genes (Myog, Ccnd3, Cdkn1c) (Figure 3, F and G), but differing in their transcriptional profiles: Proliferating I enriched for mTOR signaling, ribosomal biogenesis, and stress response, and Proliferating II showing markers of mitochondrial biogenesis, extracellular matrix (ECM) remodeling, autophagy, and cytoskeletal reorganization (Supplemental Figure 6); and one differentiated myocyte cluster (expressing Myh1 and Myh4).

The analyses did not identify a distinct cluster for quiescent/activated cells in the hypothyroid dataset. However, proliferating cells (Proliferating II) expressing Notch signaling in the uninjured hypothyroid muscle could represent activated myogenic cells. Proliferative cells were detected even in uninjured hypothyroid muscle, with a moderate increase at 5 days and a marked 10-fold rise by 14 dpi (Figure 3G). Differentiated myocytes were significantly reduced at both 5 days and 14 days in hypothyroid regenerating muscles when compared with controls (Supplemental Table 1).

GO term analysis comparing control with hypothyroid myogenic cells 5 days after muscle injury revealed enrichment of pathways related to muscle cell differentiation, activation, adaptation, and skeletal muscle contraction (Supplemental Figure 7 and Supplemental Dataset 7). By 14 dpi, control myogenic cells showed increased activation of MET-PTK2 signaling, integrin-mediated cell surface interactions, nonintegrin membrane-ECM interactions, and collagen biosynthesis (Supplemental Figure 7 and Supplemental Dataset 8). These findings suggest that hypothyroidism disrupts normal regenerative progression by reducing cellular diversity within the myogenic lineage, delaying the transition from proliferation to differentiation, and impairing the reestablishment of mature muscle fiber populations. Hypothyroid muscles showed abnormal transcriptional programs and ongoing proliferation, which might likely hinder muscle repair and function after injury.

Hypothyroidism alters proliferation and differentiation in the myogenic lineage. To investigate the effects of hypothyroidism on myoblast proliferation and differentiation, we analyzed the integrated myogenic-lineage data from control and hypothyroid groups and applied graph-based clustering. We identified 5 distinct clusters (Figure 4, A and B, and Supplemental Dataset 3) based on differential gene expression of key markers of myogenesis and cell cycle regulation (Supplemental Figures 8 and 9). The identified populations aligned closely with separate control and hypothyroid analyses, comprising quiescent/activated cells (Q/A, cluster 5), Myod1+ cells (cluster 3), differentiated myocytes (cluster 1), and 2 distinct clusters of proliferating cells: Proliferating I (cluster 4), representing actively cycling myoblasts with upregulated cell cycle genes (Ccne1, Cdk2, Ccna2, Cdk1, Ccnb1); and Proliferating II (cluster 2), exhibiting increased Myod1 and Myog expression, indicative of cells transitioning to exit the cell cycle toward differentiation (Figure 4B).

scRNA-seq and trajectory analysis reveal altered myogenic cell state transiFigure 4

scRNA-seq and trajectory analysis reveal altered myogenic cell state transitions and impaired progression in hypothyroid muscle regeneration. (A) t-SNE visualization of the integrated scRNA-seq datasets from control and hypothyroid myogenic-lineage cells, with clusters distinguished by color. (B) Graph depicting relative proportions of clusters in each sample shown as percentage. Number of cells for each sample: CTRL NI, 163; CTRL 5d, 201; CTRL 14d, 344; HYPO NI, 208; HYPO 5d, 399; HYPO 14d, 148. (C) Table showing fold change in gene expression of selected genes for cells in Myocytes (cluster 1), Quiescent/Activated (cluster 5), and Proliferating II (cluster 2) clusters, in uninjured muscle and 5 days and 14 dpi, comparing hypothyroid and control myogenic-lineage cells. (D) Monocle trajectory plots for control datasets showing the distribution of myogenic cells in 5 states. (E) Monocle trajectory plots split by time point, in uninjured muscle and 5 days and 14 dpi, showing the distribution of control myogenic cells in 5 states. (F) Graph showing the number of cells in each control Monocle trajectory state. (G) Graph showing the percentage of cells from each time point for each control Monocle trajectory state. (H) Violin plots showing gene expression for selected genes in the control-specific myocyte states. (I) Monocle trajectory plots for hypothyroid datasets showing the distribution of hypothyroid myogenic cells in 3 states. (J) Monocle trajectory plots split by time point, in uninjured muscle and 5 days and 14 dpi, showing the distribution of hypothyroid myogenic cells in 3 states. (K) Graph showing the number of cells in each hypothyroid Monocle trajectory state. (L) Graph showing the percentage of cells from each time point for each hypothyroid Monocle trajectory state. C, control; H, hypothyroid.

Comparative gene analysis between hypothyroid and control samples identified transcriptional differences across quiescent/activated cells, proliferating myoblasts, and differentiated myocytes (Figure 4C and Supplemental Dataset 9). In uninjured muscle (NI), quiescent/activated cells (cluster 5) from hypothyroid samples exhibited a pre-activated state, characterized by upregulation of activation markers Fos and Jun as well as myosin genes (Myh1, Myh3) (Figure 4C). This was accompanied by the downregulation of the thyroid hormone target genes Myod1 and Myog, and the cell cycle inhibitor p57 (Cdkn1c), compared with their euthyroid counterparts (Figure 4C).

Hypothyroid Proliferating II cells (cells poised for differentiation, cluster 2) at 5 dpi exhibited downregulation of Myod1, genes involved in cell cycle exit (Myog and Myf6), cell cycle genes, and transient myosin genes (Myh3 and Myh8) and upregulation of Cdkn2a, suggesting a potential delay in cell cycle exit (Figure 4C). PAX7 expression corroborated the single-cell trajectory delay under hypothyroidism (Supplemental Figure 10). At 5 dpi, hypothyroid muscles displayed a higher density of PAX7+ cells compared with euthyroid, whereas PAX7+ counts were comparable at baseline and 14 dpi.

Furthermore, these cells exhibited increased expression of immune-related genes, including those involved in complement activation (C1qa, C1qb, C1qc), MHC class II antigens (H2-Eb1, H2-Aa, H2-Ab1), and cathepsin family members (Ctsb, Ctss). This profile is similar to the “immunomyoblast” population described by Oprescu et al. (13), indicating ongoing interactions with immune cells, which is absent in control cells after 5 days.

In uninjured hypothyroid myocytes (cluster 1), we observed upregulation of both transient and slow myosin genes, including the fast/oxidative isoform Myh2 (note that Myh2 is not displayed in the graph because of its high expression level) and the embryonic myosin Myh3, compared with control; and downregulation of genes related to skeletal muscle differentiation, including the fast glycolytic isoform Myh4 (Figure 4C). At 14 dpi, hypothyroid myocytes (cluster 1) exhibited altered gene expression patterns related to terminal differentiation. Specifically, there was downregulation of Myh4 (predominantly expressed in type IIb fast glycolytic fibers) and Pvalb (abundant in fast muscle fibers). Conversely, there was upregulation of Myog, Myh1, Mymx, and Mymk (involved in myocyte fusion), and Car3 (highly expressed in mature slow fibers) (Figure 4C).

We then sought to determine the heterogeneity of myogenic populations as they transition through regeneration states. We performed trajectory analysis using Monocle 2 (https://cole-trapnell-lab.github.io/monocle-release/) on isolated control (Figure 4, D–H) and hypothyroid myogenic cells (Figure 4, I–L), which revealed 5 distinct states in control samples and only 3 in hypothyroid samples, supporting the reduced heterogeneity and complexity of the myogenic lineage in hypothyroid muscles. Both control and hypothyroid trajectories exhibited a similar hierarchical structure, branching into 3 main categories: Myod1+ cells, cycling/proliferating cells, and differentiated myocytes (Figure 4, D and I, and Supplemental Datasets 10 and 11). However, 2 states were uniquely identified in control samples and were absent in hypothyroid samples (states 2 and 3, Figure 4, F, G, K, and L). These states, consisting of 2 small cell populations, were predominantly located within the myocyte branch at the 14-day time point (Figure 4, E–G). Comparative gene analysis indicated that these states represented cells transitioning from proliferation to differentiation, with a transcriptional profile suggesting involvement in stem cell niche regeneration (through expression of the quiescence markers Pax7 and Cd34 and the niche-related marker Actc1), and a progression from temporary to mature fibers (Myh3, Myh8, Myh1, Myh4) (Figure 4H and Supplemental Figure 11).

Collectively, these findings suggest that thyroid hormone is essential for maintaining the diversity and fidelity of myogenic differentiation during muscle regeneration, and that lack of thyroid hormone affects MuSC activation, proliferation, and differentiation.

Hypothyroidism disrupts muscle stem cell cycle progression and alters muscle fiber composition during regeneration. To evaluate how hypothyroidism impairs regeneration by modulating MuSC proliferation and differentiation, we analyzed cell cycle phases in these cells using the FUCCI system. The system employs red (mCherry) and green (mVenus) fluorescent proteins fused to the cycling regulators CDT1 and geminin, respectively. These two proteins oscillate via posttranslational control: CDT1 accumulates in the G1 phase (mCherry+ nuclei, red), and when cells enter the S phase, it is degraded by ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis. At the same time, geminin accumulates from the early S phase through the M phase (mVenus+ nuclei, green). Both proteins are present during the G1/S transition (mCherry+mVenus+ nuclei, yellow), while in G0 and early G1, both reporters are absent, and cells have no fluorescence (19, 20). We generated mice with the FUCCI signal under the Pax7 promoter (Pax7-Fucci mice) by breeding Fucci2AR-Gt(ROSA)26Sortm1(CAG-Venus/GMNN,-Cherry/CDT1)Jkn mice with Pax7-Cre (Pax7tm1(cre)Mrc/J) mice (Figure 5A). The FUCCI reporter system activates only in cells of the myogenic lineage (expressing Pax7) once they enter the cell cycle (Figure 5B). Three days after CTX-induced injury in the TAM of Pax7-Fucci mice, we observed a marked increase of mCherry+mVenus+ nuclei (yellow, G1/S phase) and mVenus+ nuclei (green, S/G2/M phase), indicating MuSC activation and proliferation (Figure 5B). During in vitro differentiation, Pax7-Fucci cells transitioned from green/yellow (G1/S/M phases) to red (G1 phase), confirming that red (G1) cells had exited the cell cycle and differentiated into myocytes (Supplemental Figure 12).

Hypothyroidism impairs muscle stem cell cycle progression and fiber type reFigure 5

Hypothyroidism impairs muscle stem cell cycle progression and fiber type regeneration following injury. (A) Pax7-Fucci2aR mice are generated by crossing of Fucci2aR and mice expressing Cre recombinase under the Pax7 promoter (Pax7-Cre). (B) Immunofluorescence images of uninjured and injured TAM 3 days after muscle injury, showing expression of the Fucci2aR reporter fluorophores mCherry (red) and mVenus (green). Nuclei in blue. Scale bars: 50 μm. (C) Experimental design overview. Primary cells were collected from TAMs isolated from control and hypothyroid mice before injury and 5, 7, and 14 days after cardiotoxin injury (n = 3 for each group) and subjected to flow cytometry analysis. Created in BioRender (Aguiari P, 2026, https://BioRender.com/dshnhgx). (D) Representative graphs showing selection of CD31–CD45–SCA1–VCAM1+ population by flow cytometry. (E) Representative quadrant of Fucci2aR reporter mVenus and mCherry expression in the VCAM1+ population: mVenus+ (M/G2, green), mCherry+ (G1, red), mVenus+mCherry+ (G1/S, yellow), and mVenus–mCherry– (G0). (F) Superimposed dot plot graph showing proportion of MuSCs in different phases of the cell cycle in control and hypothyroid myogenic muscles before and 5, 7, and 14 dpi, as identified by flow cytometry analysis. *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001, ****P < 0.0001. (G) Experimental design overview. TAMs were isolated from control and hypothyroid mice before injury and 5, 7, 14, and 28 days after cardiotoxin injury (n = 3 for each group) and subjected to histological analysis. Created in BioRender (Aguiari P, 2026, https://BioRender.com/ksp4qn5). (H) Immunofluorescence of TAM sections from control and hypothyroid mice at different time points before and after injury: myosin type I (MYH7, magenta), type IIa (MYH2, yellow), type IIb (MYH4, green), and laminin (white). Type IIx (MYH1) unstained. Scale bars: 100 μm. (I) Histogram plot showing proportion of different fiber types in TAM during regeneration at 0, 7, 14, and 28 days after cardiotoxin-induced injury. Data are presented as mean ± SEM. n = 3. Two-way ANOVA was used for statistical analysis. ***P < 0.001, ****P < 0.0001, in hypothyroid compared with time point–matched control fibers. The experiment was repeated 3 times independently under identical conditions. C, control; H, hypothyroid; CTRL, control; HYPO, hypothyroid.

Cell cycle phase distribution in MuSCs was analyzed in hypothyroid and euthyroid mice at multiple time points after injury (0, 5, 7, and 14 days) (Figure 5C). For this, we used established markers to isolate quiescent/activated MuSCs (CD31–CD45–SCA1–VCAM+ cells) (21), and assessed the FUCCI signal in this population via flow cytometry (Figure 5, D and E).

Cell cycle analysis showed that, in uninjured hypothyroid muscle, MuSCs predominantly occupied the G1 phase (red), with a reduced presence in the S/G2/M phase (Figure 5F). After injury, hypothyroid MuSCs exhibited delayed cell cycle progression, with a lower proportion of cells in G1 and an increased proportion in S phase at days 7 and 14 (Figure 5F). These findings confirm that hypothyroidism affects MuSC proliferation and differentiation and may impair the regenerative progression.

To assess how hypothyroidism affects muscle fiber composition during regeneration and confirm that the differences seen in scRNA-seq in myocytes translate into phenotypical changes in mature fibers, we analyzed the whole-tissue fiber composition of regenerating TAM in both hypothyroid and euthyroid mice at 0, 7, 14, and 28 days and 2 months after injury (Figure 5, G and H). In euthyroid muscles, fiber composition remained consistent over time, with a prevalence of fast glycolytic type IIb fibers, and a temporary increase of type II fibers (Figure 5, H and I). Hypothyroid muscles, however, displayed a significant reduction in type IIb fibers at all time points after injury, accompanied by an increase in type IIx fibers at days 7, 14, and 28 after injury and in type IIa fibers at days 14 and 28. These alterations in fiber type and size indicate that hypothyroidism disrupts regeneration of normal muscle architecture and leads to lasting changes in muscle structure and potential function.

Dysregulated immune and fibro-adipogenic progenitor responses in skeletal muscle regeneration during hypothyroidism. Skeletal muscle regeneration is a highly coordinated process involving both myogenic and nonmyogenic cell populations, including immune cells and fibro-adipogenic progenitors (FAPs). Our scRNA-seq analysis revealed dynamic changes in these populations during regeneration in hypothyroid and control muscles (Figure 2, D and E). Given these observations, we investigated whether hypothyroidism contributes to alterations in the composition and behavior of these nonmyogenic populations.

To examine immune cell dynamics, we selected 6,753 cells from immune clusters (myeloid, lymphoid, and mixed immune cell clusters; Supplemental Figure 13 and Supplemental Dataset 12) and performed unsupervised graph-based clustering. Differential gene expression analysis identified 17 distinct immune cell clusters that we broadly aggregated into 3 groups: monocytes and macrophages, patrolling macrophages, and lymphoid cells (Figure 6A and Supplemental Figure 13, A and B). Notably, the proportion of monocytes and macrophages was 4.4-fold higher in hypothyroid muscles at 5 dpi compared with controls (Figure 6, B and C). Given the critical role of pro- and antiinflammatory macrophages in muscle repair, we further analyzed the shifts in their proportions during regeneration. Proinflammatory (Ccl6+) cells were 5.9-fold less in the hypothyroid muscle 5 dpi, while the antiinflammatory (C1qa+) cells were 2.8-fold higher at the same time point (Figure 6, D and E).

Thyroid hormone deficiency alters the immune and FAP landscape during skeleFigure 6

Thyroid hormone deficiency alters the immune and FAP landscape during skeletal muscle regeneration. (A) t-SNE visualization of integrated scRNA-seq datasets from control and hypothyroid immune cells, with clusters distinguished by color. (B) Proportions of cells (graph, top panel) in each cluster shown as a percentage of control and hypothyroid immune cell muscle before injury and 5 and 14 dpi. Bottom panel: Fold change in cell proportion in hypothyroid compared with control samples for each cluster. In uninjured (NI) datasets, the immune cell samples were too small to be compared (/). Number of cells for each sample: CTRL NI, 128; CTRL 5d, 3,381; CTRL 14d, 548; HYPO NI, 72; HYPO 5d, 2,052; HYPO 14d, 572. (C) t-SNE visualization of control and hypothyroid immune cell scRNA-seq data colored by cluster and grouped by time points. (D) Table showing fold change of the number of proinflammatory (Ccl6+) and antiinflammatory (C1qa+) macrophages in hypothyroid versus control muscles at 5 and 14 dpi. In uninjured (NI) datasets, the immune cell samples were too small to be compared (/). (E) t-SNE visualization of immune cells at 5 dpi in control and hypothyroid scRNA-seq datasets colored by expression of Ccl6 (proinflammatory macrophages, blue), C1qa (antiinflammatory macrophages, red), and Cd75 (patrolling macrophages, green). Cells negative for the 3 markers are shown in black. (F) t-SNE plot of integrated scRNA-seq datasets from control and hypothyroid FAPs, with clusters distinguished by color. (G) Table describing FAP clusters and their functional roles based on gene expression classification, cluster labeling, and fold change (FC) in cell number between hypothyroid and control. Roman numerals represent the cluster numbers used in the text; asterisks indicate FC values for clusters of more than 100 cells, which are underlined, FC > 1.5 in red; FC < –1.5 in blue. (H) Histogram bar graph showing relative abundance of FAPs and muscle before injury and 5 and 14 dpi. Number of cells for each sample: CTRL NI, 1,648; CTRL 5d, 919; CTRL 14d, 3,597; HYPO NI, 655; HYPO 5d, 1,784; HYPO 14d, 1,875. (I) Condition-specific t-SNE plots illustrating distribution of FAP clusters in control and hypothyroid muscles before injury and 5 and 14 dpi. C, control; H, hypothyroid; CTRL, control; HYPO, hypothyroid.

To characterize FAP dynamics, we identified cell clusters exhibiting upregulation of FAP-associated genes across all datasets, yielding a total of 10,478 FAPs, which were subsequently subjected to subclustering analysis (Figure 6F, Supplemental Figure 14, and Supplemental Dataset 13). Graph-based clustering of the integrated FAP dataset identified 9 distinct subpopulations (clusters I–IX, Figure 6G). Based on differential gene expression analysis of known FAP markers (13, 22) (Supplemental Figure 14A), these clusters were classified according to their roles in myogenic regeneration (Figure 6G).

A different distribution of FAP subpopulations was observed between hypothyroid and control muscles across different time points (Figure 6, H and I). In uninjured muscle, we identified 2 homeostatic FAP populations (clusters I and II) characterized by genes associated with ECM production, turnover, and cytokine expression profiles known to inhibit MuSC differentiation and promote overall muscle growth. A third FAP population (cluster III) exhibited enrichment of genes encoding chemokines involved in monocyte and neutrophil recruitment. One of the 2 homeostatic FAP populations (cluster II) was increased in hypothyroid, noninjured (NI) muscles (Figure 6, H and I, and Supplemental Figure 14B). At 5 dpi, both control and hypothyroid muscle showed a reduction in homeostatic populations, with hypothyroid muscle exhibiting a greater decrease (Figure 6, H and I, and Supplemental Figure 14B). At this time point, a proliferative FAP population (cluster IV) and an activated FAP population (cluster V) were identified and comprised the larger percentage of the total FAPs. The activated FAP population is defined by expression of cytokine genes associated with recruitment of monocytes/macrophages and support of MuSC proliferation and differentiation. The proportion of activated FAPs increased 1.3-fold in hypothyroid muscles compared with controls 5 days after muscle injury (Figure 6, H and I, and Supplemental Figure 14B).

At 14 dpi, the homeostatic FAP populations responsible for ECM remodeling increased compared with 5 dpi. However, they were still underrepresented in hypothyroid muscles, showing 1.5-fold and 2.3-fold reductions compared with control muscles (Figure 6, H and I, and Supplemental Figure 14B). The percentage of proliferating and activated FABs was low at 14 days, with a trend of a higher proportion for the hypothyroid muscle compared with the control (Supplemental Figure 14B). Furthermore, a key FAP subpopulation (cluster VI) known to support MuSC self-renewal and asymmetric division (22) was 3-fold reduced (3.0-fold) in hypothyroid muscles, suggesting a long-term deficit in MuSC maintenance and regenerative potential (Figure 6, H and I, and Supplemental Figure 14B). In contrast, FAPs that promote MuSC differentiation and fusion (cluster VII) were overrepresented, exhibiting a 2.2-fold increase in hypothyroid muscles (Figure 6, G–I, and Supplemental Figure 14B).

Two FAP subpopulations, one aiding monocyte and neutrophil recruitment while inhibiting MuSC differentiation and promoting proliferation (cluster VIII) and another involved in regulatory T cell–mediated immunomodulation (cluster IX), were rare in hypothyroid and control muscles, but hypothyroid muscles showed higher cluster VIII and lower cluster IX 5 dpi (Figure 6, H and I, and Supplemental Figure 14B).

These findings suggest that hypothyroidism disrupts the normal progression of muscle repair, potentially leading to impaired regeneration due to dysregulated ECM remodeling, inflammatory responses, and MuSC maintenance.

Direct and indirect actions of thyroid hormone receptor signaling during skeletal muscle regeneration. To dissect how thyroid hormone regulates both myogenic and nonmyogenic compartments during repair, we quantified Thra, Thrb, Dio2, and Dio3 expression across major populations (Figure 7A). Thra was prevalent in FAPs and myogenic progenitors, Thrb was scarce, and Dio2 was enriched in stromal and myogenic cells, indicating multiple potential entry points for T3 availability and receptor-mediated activation within skeletal muscle.

Thyroid hormone (T3) signaling and downstream regulatory programs during muFigure 7

Thyroid hormone (T3) signaling and downstream regulatory programs during muscle regeneration. (A) Percentage of cells in each population expressing Thra, Thrb, Dio2, and Dio3. (B) Temporal modeling of Thra/b activity (generalized additive model [GAM], k = 3). GAM-like fits of VIPER-inferred normalized enrichment scores (NESs; mean ± SEM) for Thra (top) and Thrb (bottom). Lines show temporal trends; ribbons denote ± SEM. Asterisks indicate statistically significant divergence between CTRL and HYPO trajectories (**P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001, ANOVA comparing GAM smooths). (C) Line plots show CollecTRI-VIPER NESs for proliferative (Myc/E2f) and oxidative (Foxo/Ppargc1a) transcriptional programs across cells. Each line represents the average program activity per condition and time point. In FAPs, hypothyroidism suppressed the Myc/E2f cycling module at baseline and 5 days post-injury (dpi) but reactivated it at 14 dpi, while the oxidative Foxo/Ppargc1a program showed the opposite trend: early induction and late repression. Myogenic cells showed a similar inversion of proliferative and oxidative trajectories, whereas myeloid populations exhibited only a transient oxidative increase at 5 dpi. (D and E) Tile heatmap displaying hypothyroid-induced changes in LR interactions stratified by sender (rows) and receiver (columns) for each pathway family across the 3 regeneration stages. The color scale encodes the effect size (HYPO – CTRL). This figure resolves the directionality of communication. Asterisks indicate FDR-adjusted Wilcoxon’s P values (*P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001, ****P < 0.0001). (F) CollecTRI-VIPER transcriptional modeling and LR pathway analysis were integrated to compare direct (Thr regulon) and indirect (ECM, IGF-1, IL-6, Notch) effects across myogenic, FAP, and myeloid lineages. β-Coefficients were summarized as qualitative activation (arrow up), repression (arrow down), or weak effects at early and late stages of regeneration.

Next, we used the VIPER (Virtual Inference of Protein-activity by Enriched Regulon analysis) algorithm, which allows computational inference of protein activity from gene expression profile data, to infer Thra and Thrb regulon activity. We applied the CollecTRI-VIPER framework on our scRNA-seq data (validated by 78% concordance with DoRothEA; Supplemental Figure 15). Unlike differential expression analyses that measure changes in individual gene abundance, VIPER infers functional transcription factor activity from the coordinated regulation of its downstream targets (the regulon) (23, 24). Thus, “THR activity” here refers to the inferred activation state of the Thra/b regulons, independent of Thra or Thrb mRNA expression.

Temporal modeling of normalized enrichment scores across lineages revealed distinct, cell-specific trajectories (Figure 7B). In the control muscle, Thra/b activity rose sharply between 0 and 5 dpi and normalized by 14 dpi, particularly in myogenic cells and FAPs. Under hypothyroidism, this induction was blunted or delayed: Thra activity remained low, while Thrb displayed a transient rise 5 dpi followed by decline. Myeloid cells showed minimal change, consistent with indirect modulation via paracrine cues. These divergent trajectories were also confirmed by bootstrapped confidence intervals (Supplemental Figure 16, A and B).

To evaluate how thyroid hormone signaling integrates with regenerative control, we focused on Myc/E2f and Foxo/Ppargc1a regulons (Figure 7C and Supplemental Figure 17A), which respectively govern proliferative expansion and oxidative maturation of myogenic precursors. As for Thra/b, these activities represent inferred transcriptional output of the entire program, not expression of individual pathway genes. VIPER infers the coordinated activation state of transcriptional modules from the collective behavior of their targets, allowing assessment of how proliferative and oxidative programs are transcriptionally engaged in each condition. Under euthyroid conditions, proliferative activity peaked early, and oxidative programs rose later, marking the normal switch from expansion to differentiation (25, 26). Hypothyroidism inverted this pattern: proliferative Myc/E2f activity was suppressed at baseline and early phases but markedly increased by 14 dpi, whereas oxidative activity peaked prematurely at 5 dpi and then declined. The apparent discrepancy with the high number of cycling cells observed at 5 dpi under hypothyroidism reflects a decoupling between cell abundance and transcriptional drive: although more cells enter the cycling compartment under hypothyroidism, their Myc/E2f regulon activity is reduced, indicating inefficient or incomplete proliferative engagement. Thra/b activity correlated positively with Myc/E2f and negatively with Foxo/Ppargc1a scores (Supplemental Figure 17B), demonstrating that thyroid hormone directly synchronizes proliferative and metabolic transitions in regenerative lineages.

Finally, ligand-receptor (LR) mapping identified remodeling of intra- and inter-population paracrine networks under hypothyroidism (Figure 7, D and E, and Supplemental Figures 18 and 19). Hypothyroidism preferentially altered ECM/integrin, IGF-1, IL-6 family, and Notch/Jagged signaling, with distinct temporal patterns (Supplemental Figure 18). At baseline, matrix-integrin signaling between FAPs and myocytes was reduced. By day 5, however, it became enriched in myogenic-myeloid exchanges, while FAPs acted largely as receivers. By day 14, FAPs emerged as predominant matrix-signal senders, particularly toward myogenic cells, establishing reciprocal FAP-myogenic communication (Figure 7D and Supplemental Figure 19). IGF-1 and IL-6 pathways showed transient amplification, and Notch/Jagged interactions became globally activated at 14 dpi (Figure 7, D and E).

To dissect direct nuclear versus indirect paracrine influences of thyroid hormone signaling, we performed linear modeling of CollecTRI-VIPER transcriptional programs (Myc/E2f, Foxo/Ppargc1a) as a function of THR regulon activity and LR pathway scores (ECM, IGF-1, IL-6, Notch). T3-THR signaling orchestrates regeneration through both direct transcriptional and indirect paracrine mechanisms (Figure 7F). In myogenic cells, Thr activity was associated positively with Myc/E2f proliferative programs and inversely with Foxo/Ppargc1a oxidative programs. In FAPs, Thr links were weaker and largely mediated through paracrine remodeling, characterized by early ECM/IGF-1 and late IL-6/Notch pathway activation. Myeloid populations displayed only mild or context-dependent effects, consistent with secondary modulation (Figure 7F). Together, these data establish that thyroid hormone drives regeneration by synchronizing myogenic transcriptional programs with temporally coordinated stromal-immune signaling dynamics. In hypothyroidism, this coordination is disrupted, delaying Thr-dependent activation and prolonging compensatory stromal and cytokine signaling, ultimately impairing regenerative timing and efficiency.

Comments (0)

No login
gif